Will the current vacuum industry ever change to something like it used to be?

VacuumLand – Vintage & Modern Vacuum Enthusiasts

Help Support VacuumLand:

oliveoiltinfoil

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 15, 2014
Messages
561
Location
England, UK
Looking at citroenbx's link about vintage vacuum catalogues, from the 70's to the 00's, it brought back how vacuums, and pretty much any other white good domestic appliances used to be. In so many way, it really brings home how vastly things have changed, so quickly. One thing I noticed was that, it seemed catalogue companies actually knew a little bit about the vacuums they were selling. I was seeing "clean fan motor" advertised on the dyson dc01, the infamous "British made" logos and who can forget the "beats as it sweeps as it cleans."

Now I am only 31 and half English, half german, growing up in Germany until I was 17 but I do remember looking through these catalogues during the 80's and 90's. These cleaners just look so much better quality to what they are now. It is amazing to see again "400, 500, 600 watt motors" and bagged cleaners a plenty.

What I am trying to get at is the current trend of cheaply built, nasty made vacuum. Looking at a few pages in these catalogues and seeing cleaners for 20 and 30 quid (would be more these days because of inflation) but cheap basic vaccums and even these looked well built and well thought out, probably all made in the west or Japan.

Nearly all these vacuums these days are made in china, with locally sourced, cheap parts, nasty nosier motors and cheap plastic bagless containers with poor manufacturing and quality control, at one point it seemed that things would never go back to the good old days. It's funny, we never thought anything at the time of getting out the dyson and It saying "made in Derby, UK, or the Electrolux Swedish made", but how we crave it now.

But recently, I am starting to see a couple of cleaners here and there with manufacturing being brought back to western countries. Now this post could go on forever explaining why, but I am awear that western and Japanese companies who were investing in china are now starting to pull out for a couple of strong reasons, chief among which being that manufacturing costs in china are now getting expensive. As human rights and environmentalist activists get nosier and more powerful, pushing up labour costs and green taxes being introduced out there "sort of) it is now no where near as cheap to build your white goods there. Indeed sony will be build the ps4 in brazil rather than china next year (but that may be to do with japanes/Chinese relations being very rocky at the moment). You also have the copy cat culture out there who have stolen western designs of not just cars and clothes, but vacuums and appliances. There was a copy of a dyson being sold on alibaba not so long ago.

Also, I would imagine its now very expensive to ship these products form china to Europe and Americas, not to mention time consuming. I also guess people are getting fed up of cheap nasty quality vacuums. Even vacuums costing £200/300 are made in china and most of them, not all however, are cheaply made and throw away items. More people are buying sebos and mieles as they are German/European built machines. But even some Electrolux and AEG moels are being built in the EU now. There is the revised AEG rechargeable stick vac mentioned on here not long ago, saying it was "made in the EU". I would imagine that its probably Poland or Slovakia, eastern Europe, but I guess wages there are probably as cheap as china without the worries of stealing designs, dangerous materials being used or shipping costs or waiting times.

Before the made in china craze was a thing, a few products were being made in eastern Europe and they were still decent quality, with a lot of the parts still being made in the native countries of the people who made the item.

Finally, I guess the other reason which has a big part to play is the advancement of automated manufacturing. I was watching a documentary about bosch not so long ago making car parts including O2 sensors, air meters, ABS and even ECU units which were being made in asia up until not so long ago when they moved back to Germany, the UK and Austria. The guy at bosch said essentially (not directly) they had concerns over spies working for Chinese state owned electronic companies taking technology, quality problems and also supplier problems, as bsoch would tell a Chinese factory how to make a certain product, and the end product ended up being completely inferior and wrong to the point they couldn't use it. A laser cutting company in Britain had the same problem, costing both bosch and this clothing company hundreds of thousands of pounds.

But bosch said that because of automated manufacturing, the fact that once you have bought a robot, you don't pay it a wage, it pays for itself over time, insures consistent quality throughout several thousand batches of parts, and also puts working back into Europe, he said they probably couldn't make the product cheaper. It was profitable, but ended up making a quality product.

So, does this exciting, roe recent trend hold any merits? Do you think we could finally start seeing "made in EC, UK and USA" back on our vacuums ?
 
Oh how I used to love getting the new Argos Catalogue & flicking through page after page of Bush, Hinari, Goblin, Dirt Devil & Morphy Richards Bagged Cylinders, & about £25 roughly.

Sadly, those days are long gone, BUT I hope that we see some more bagged models of cleaner on the market when the New Regulations begin this September because there are barely any cheapie bagged cylinders at Argos any more, only the Value ones.

Daewoo is the only company who still produce a small bagged cylinder, the RC350BK which retails for about £30.
 
Even until recently...

... in 2004 you could buy a Panasonic MCE-468, albeit a 1600 watt cleaner, but for £69.95, it's a good cleaner and the same design has been knocking on 20 years now.


 


It just shows you don't have to pay loads for a decent cleaner. When the Panasonic was for sale in 2004 a Dyson DC14 cost £300, £230 more! And I know which I'd rather have! (Panasonic)
 
Well, I live in the US but can still relate. I too would like to see more manufacturing in the home country (US). The vacuum market here is also quite boring. It seems bagless uprights are all anyone cares about anymore. If anyone has a vacuum it seems to be a bagless upright for the house and a shop vac for anything else.

I'd like to see more canister vacuums, which many stores here do not sell at all, the closest thing to canister is Shark Lift Away. I'd also like to see more bagged vacuums, most stores here sell only one of a few models, the Bissell Powerforce, and Hoover Tempo, if they have any.

My favorite big box store for vacuum selection, and the last one that seems to push bagged machines as well as canisters, Sears, is not doing well, and it's unfortunate.

It's crazy thinking back to how cool I thought the first bagless cyclonic uprights we had here (Fantom) were, and never expecting that one day that's about all there would be on the market!
 
Thing is though, in 2004 you were able to buy Dysons at that price because there was a lot more money around then.

But saying that, even in 2004 you were still able to buy cheapie bagged vacs which were always my preference.
 
I'm no expert, but here's what I know

<span style="font-family: 'times new roman', times; font-size: 12pt;">Take a look at Tacony Manufacturing, who assembles Riccar, Simplicity and Maytag vacuums. They have actually been able to increase production in Missouri in recent years, and their products are very quality made. But companies like them are far and few between. However you also have to keep in mind that we live in a globalized economy now. This is not necessary a bad thing. Not everything can or should be made domestically. If Japan can make a better product than someone in the United States, I just want the better product, ethically and responsibly made of course.</span>


<span style="font-family: 'times new roman', times; font-size: 12pt;"> </span>


<span style="font-family: 'times new roman', times; font-size: 12pt;">Anyway, the bagless trend is slightly to blame for the current situation. People don't want to pay for maintenance if they don't have to, and bagless machines at least <em style="font-family: Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif; font-size: 11px;">appear </em>to look maintenance free.  The complexity of those machines require larger motors, which draw more electricity, burn out faster, and then need to be replaced sooner. But the cost of the machines are so low in the first place, people are willing to just endlessly buy cheap products.   There is a huge demand for bagless, even in the second hand market, and in order to make money most companies have to produce them. Vacuum companies used to make money off the sale of disposable bags, but since nobody buys bagged  anymore, they're forced to produce cheap disposable bagless vacuums that are bought every few years. And the western disposable consumer culture since the 1980s deems this acceptable, and in many ways encourages it. Buy what you want, throw it away, repeat. It's an endless cycle.</span>


<span style="font-family: 'times new roman', times; font-size: 12pt;"> </span>


<span style="font-family: 'times new roman', times; font-size: 12pt;">I can only imagine two ways to break the cycle, talking about vacuums specially. The first would be to educate the consumer. Bagged vacuums generally last longer, and repairing durable appliances compared to replacing cheap ones is generally less expense in the long run. Consumers want to save money, and if they know how to, they will naturally choose more durable machines. Increased demand for durable vacuums could eventually lead to a better market. Will this ever happen? I doubt it, but demand is really the biggest motive for change. </span>


<span style="font-family: 'times new roman', times; font-size: 12pt;"> </span>


<span style="font-family: 'times new roman', times; font-size: 12pt;">The second way is how they decided to move forward in Europe, which as you know was to regulate motor power consumption. It can be difficult to produce a high-performance cyclonic machines with smaller motors. Since most companies try to keep costs as low as humanly possible, I bet most of them will just rerelease basic efficient bagged machines, with better filtration of course. Although we could also see some exciting new efficient bagless designs as well. Either way, I see the new EU regulations a good step in the right direction.</span>


<span style="font-family: 'times new roman', times; font-size: 12pt;"> </span>


<span style="font-family: 'times new roman', times; font-size: 12pt;">The future looks more exciting each day. We have a long way to go to become more sustainable, but things are definitely looking up. </span>


<span style="font-family: 'times new roman', times; font-size: 12pt;"> </span>


<span style="font-family: 'times new roman', times; font-size: 12pt;"> </span>
 
As I sit here in my armchair, directly next to me is my 1986 Hoover Junior U1104 which has a sticker on the handle proudly proclaiming "This one's made in Britain". Will we ever see that again from Hoover? No.

It is my belief that any vacuum cleaner manufacturers who have moved production to China won't move again, unless it is to somewhere with even cheaper labour.

The only hope we have now (in my opinion) is that the manufacturers who still produce vacuums in the UK and USA et al will continue to do so.

Thus, my answer to your question is no, the vacuum cleaner industry will never be remotely like what it once was. It will change, you can be certain of that, but not for the better.

On that happy note...
 
Oh you are trying to tempt me again with a Junior U1104. I adore those.

To be honest Oli, and knowing some of those catalogues, you still got cheap vacuums that were made in places like Poland and where, if it wasn't a major brand, the bags were devilishly hard to find. Even finding bags for some premium brands "back in the day" like AEG were difficult to find!

A bit like Argos' exclusive branded bagged vacuums, these days..or Tesco or ASDA variants whenever they bring out bagged cylinders. Well before there were supermarket alternatives, Comet, Dixons and Currys had their own exclusive brands with cheap Chinese built imports and again, with dust bags hard to find.

One day, we may return to a manufacturing base in the UK, but it may take longer than expected.

Unlike a lot of opinions that have been passed here and in years past, I am not against Chinese built vacuums.

I've had a few that have lasted a long time - cue Morphy Richards/Goblin Ace and their variants including the Hoover Studio vacs - ALL of them have long 1.8 metre hoses and are slightly heavier than the cheapie ones now in 2014. They are also a bit more durable even if sometimes you get smaller naff cleaning tools.

The beauty of those ones are that because they sold in so many variants, dust bags are forever available for those vacuums - which is a telling sign that not all Chinese vacs are crap.
 
It isn't so much the manufacturing abroad which I think has caused the problem, more that as the years have progressed, attitudes have changed. Day by day, less people were bothered about buying British.

In the 69 short years since the 2nd world war ended, the world as a whole has evolved massively, with more manufacturing than ever, given the widespread use of gas and electricity, which, when you think about it, is still a relatively recent discovery when compared to the 1850 or so years which occurred without having it. It won't be all that long where we reach a break-even point where the number of years certain items were made in the UK is exceeded by the number of years it has been made elsewhere. But as generations of UK citizens die off, all of this gets forgotten. I bet many of the young people buying irons and toasters today have never known anything other than imports.

Until a "Buy British" campaign is held, I don't see much of anything coming back here in a hurry.
 
And Mr Murray...

You are 18 not 98, enjoy your youth and if you are lucky enough to make old age, you can take the chance to sound like me all you want to then. Most people your age wouldn't know what eccentric means, let alone become it.
 
I don't think having a troubled industry has helped though. Some major brands required their heads examined. BLC/Austin Rover are a case in point. Even with Honda's ownership, the company looked as if they were on an even keel - buyers were happy to buy up Rover cars even though they knew that there was a Honda underneath. When Rover were sold to BMW and then ended up being wound down, I think that is when the problems began. By then the UK government could not save Britain's sole car brand.

It isn't just attitudes that have changed but also lifestyle and more women getting out of the home and leading careers. Even back in the 1980s when equality was finally becoming respected (note I don't mean understood or qualified as that occurred much earlier) brands were still using women for advertising vacuums, stay-at-home-products etc.
 
Women

Well dare I even say it, that even though advertising may have moved on as point of principle, it seems to me that the running of a home is not much less the job of a woman than it always was. I think if anything there is probably a lot more team-work going on, and also men may have specific "womens work" activities (as it used to be known) which they carry out, but I do think society still defaults to women when it comes to running a home. I wonder sometimes how long it will be before real equality exists. I don't expect to see it in my lifetime.
 
The same thing here in the states too

I miss the same things you guys miss. I used to look forward every year for the new catalogues from different department stores to come out to see how each year model changed and what new or different brand they were carrying. I used to also look forward to going to them to see and try them out but now seems like everything's the same in each store. If you want diversity you have to go to a speciality store and pay high for them or wait for Ebay, Craigslist or any other placebo find what you're looking for. . I love the older well built machines that had a personality and they each sounded different, not like today's vacuums...they all sound the same. Also I would like if they all went back to making machines like they did back in the late 70's through the 80's ... They lasted and are now harder to find in decent condition. We're all in this together hang in there ..maybe if we protest..lol..they might get the message! Cheers guys!!! Mark D.
 
You know I was just thinking

Which could be dangerous that they should start making dual-voltage (120/220) machines so we could do a pond swap of vacuums. There sure are quite a few I'd like to try from over there. Cheers again!!! Mark D.
 
The comments on the travails of Bosch and Chinese manufacturing remind me of the Chinese Bosch made points sets for BMW flat twins from 1970-1981 that were manufactured incorrectly, making setting the point gap impossible. Sigh.

You can buy US made vacuums from Kirby of course, but also from Simplicity, Riccar, Maytag (only uprights at this point),CleanMax, Oreck and I am pretty sure Aerus Lux. Most are high end vacuums however Oreck and Maytag anchor the affordable end of the price spectrum.

There are also Garage Vac (they have a fun video on their website) and a cool little all metal torpedo of a canister from MetroVac.

Lots of US made vacuums. Shop happy.
 
Aerus are still made in the US, except for the canister of the Platinum which is manufactured in the EU with final assembly in the US (different circuit boards and LCD screen) and the sidekicks which are now made in China.
 
Have I gone mad????!!!!????

The Reply above caught my eye.... 'different circuit boards and LCD screen'....

Since when did a Vacuum Cleaner need more than an on/off switch?? It's sole purpose in life is to pick up dirt from the floor and put it in a bag/box!!

It is this fascination with 'Gizmotrinics' (among other things) which is driving costs up, and sending manufacturing jobs abroad. 'Clean Rooms' for making 'chips' and circuit boards cost a lot more than injection moulding / die-casting machines, so the vacuums are now made where the 'chips' are made. Quite simple economics, really.... :-(

All best

Dave T
 

Latest posts

Back
Top