Why So Many Models?

VacuumLand – Vintage & Modern Vacuum Enthusiasts

Help Support VacuumLand:

shrink1982

Active member
Joined
Oct 10, 2015
Messages
41
Location
Indianapolis
Why do vacuum manufacturers produce so many models? Perhaps if they focused on a few, they would get the quality right. I mean, I can't even keep Miele straight. There are so many canisters with different options, better build quality, and power heads it boggles my mind. Sebo isn't quite as bad and Kirby and companies like Rainbow, etc. are the only manufacturers that seem to have one model at a time. It just amazes me. Look at Shark, for example; there are so many versions of the same few vacuums. For me have a good, better, and best canister and upright and call it a day.
 
Same.....

reason GM used to have so many car 'divisions'.  They figured out the buying public can be duped into believing they are buying something different, even if they use the same parts. All they had to do was just tweak the appearance a bit. That was primarily the success of Kenmore...Sears didn't manufacture anything but sold cheaper than name brands.....essentially the same products.


 


Kevin
 
'Line extensions' is Marketing 101. "I'd buy this if only it had that...". People are funny in that way. Because consumers segment themselves in so many different ways adding to the model proliferation drives overall volume throughput. How do you increase sales when things start to flatten out? Add a new model. Sophisticated marketers do robust consumer testing through focus groups, quantitative research and A/B testing to land on what is that next tweak that will pull in additional consumers to consider the brand. If you're not growing, you're dying.
 
Marketing ploy, like Tseg explained.  You can mix and match parts, add or subtract parts to make a bottom line through a deluxe line. The possibilities are almost endless. Sometimes, almost by accident, they create a bottom or middle unit that outperforms their deluxe unit.  Sometimes it's deliberate though; the consumer figures out the best 'bargain' is in the bottom or middle unit and buys that predominately. The manufacturer doesn't care as long as the top line model pays for itself.  Kind of like a pyramid sales model with the flagship unit on the top.


 


Where I think they error is when they start confusing the consumer with too many models or no clear distinction between models.  Say for example you buy a middle model, but don't see any difference against the bottom model and nothing in the literature to guide you in your decision.


 


Kevin


<div id="ext_searchPromptBtn" style="top: 8px; left: 190px; z-index: auto;"> </div>
 
We have the oposite problem here in South Africa ... two few models to choose from. Hoover does One upright here, if its too small buy another brand if you can find one that is. Electrolux ( your Eureka ) had 3 uprights but they pulled out of the vacuum business here.
 
Hoover did that for decades. (no pun intenede)

They'd make a vacuum w/ a shorter cord, no light, half a bumper, snap bag...the Convertible "Special". same motor, etc but a lower cost.
They'd manufacture 2 models at a time sometimes.
Care were similar. Pontiac and Chevrolet would be almost the same..... different names.
Sadly, Ford made Thunderbirds look just like everything for a while. it was awful.
Lincoln did the same thing.
there was a time when a Lincoln LOOKED like a Lincoln, T-Birds too, etc.
 
Now that....

you mention it, that's the convertible I bought in college! It had no light, snap bag and was pink.  I remember thinking the cord could be longer...lol. I don't know Hoover models...thanks for that!


 


Kevin


<div id="ext_searchPromptBtn" style="top: 3px; left: 8px; z-index: auto;"> </div>
 
number of models

Sometimes this is done to satisfy different market segments, for example, if someone has all hard wood floors, there would be no need for a power nozzle if purchasing a canister vacuum. On the other hand, for carpet, in most cases, you would want a spinning brush, so a power nozzle canister would make sense. Even then, that's only two models. One company that has lots and lots of models, at least in their canister line up is Miele. I think there are 15 or more models. I do think this can be confusing, although once you look at their models, there is some method to the madness. Miele has three canister series, C1, C2, and C3. The C1 classic is a full sized canister with basic features such as a knob for the speed control. The C2 compact series is a bit smaller, the down side to this series is that it takes smaller bags requiring the bag to be changed more often. The C3 complete series has the bells and whistles such as electronic speed control and a slightly longer cord. Once you decide which series you want, you can then choose the model in that series that includes the accessories you need. One thing I think manufacturers should do when it comes to canisters is, if you choose a model that does not include a power nozzle, it should still provide the ability to be upgraded later. As far as I know, the straight suction models from Miele, Sebo, and the straight suction version of the Riccar Prima and Simplicity wonder cannot be upgraded by simply purchasing the electric hose and power nozzle, if your requirements change, you would need to purchase an entirely new vacuum, or I guess you could use the Volt power nozzle, but still, if a company makes both a straight suction and power nozzle model, the straight suction model should always contain the circuitry to be upgraded to an electric hose.
Mike
 
upgrading Miele c3

That's good to know, I have heard that all Miele canisters had this, but my C1 Olympus definitely does not. Since there are canisters in the C1 series that can use electric hoses, Miele should have included this on their C1 series as well. There are a few ways to retrofit straight suction canisters with electric power nozzles, don't bother with the turbine nozzles, they are loud, will rob the vacuum of cleaning power in order to spin the turbine and clog much too easily. You can get the volt battery powered nozzle, this is made by Tacony and is based on the Simplicity Freedom cordless, there's no bag on it, just a handle end to receive a standard hose from a canister or central vacuum. This nozzle cleans very well, there are only two changes I would make to it. First, use a cog or geared belt rather than a rubber belt, I know this was done for longer run time, but I think the trade off still would have been worth it. The other change would be to better seal the nozzle on the inside. When vacuuming things such as cat litter, some of it gets inside the nozzle but is not pulled through by the airflow. I can tell mine has a bit of that inside, at some point I will open it and clean it out, but it should be totally sealed to prevent that kind of thing.
The other way to add a power nozzle to a straight suction canister is to purchase a power nozzle cord, there is a 35 foot cord that plugs in to an outlet, and the other end has a two prong mini female connector to plug in a power nozzle, kind of cluttered, but it works.
Mike
 
I know turbo heads are hated on these forums but when looking at the Miele Turbo head reviews by many hundreds of users across 4 countries on-line sellers, this head has rave reviews. Low single digits rate it a 1 or 2 with more than 9 in 10 rating it a 4 or 5. I value that testimony much more than any critical review.
 
I couldn't agree more, some companies offer so many models but the good old standards such a Kirby, Filter Queen, Areus, Rainbow and Air-Way had mainly one model.

Electrolux did offer economy models and still does but they all were of good quality.

Hoover always amazed me, they offered different models with different features but the motor and brush roll were the same in all. At least Eureka offered different brush roll styles.

Now Shark, Bissell, Hoover, Royal and many other are all starting to look alike. One comes out with a different style and the rest follow.

If I had to have only one vacuum, it would be a Kirby. It is a tried and true design that has lasted the test of time. I would also consider a top of the line Blue Line Sanitaire Upright with a good tool set.

My famous line "bagless bad - anything with a bag good!"
 
Kirby is most definitely a brand which has a single model that is produced for X number of years, and even within all those years, there are minor changes and some new accessories.

The period running between the Heritage II and the Legend II, from 1984 to 1991, seems to be most evolutionary.

~Ben
 
models with same motor

All of the Miele canisters use the same motor. I'm not sure how many different motors Electrolux went through, I know when the super J came out they introduced a new motor, when you get in to the plastic models such as the diplomat, embassador, advantage, 2100, hope I have those models right, all of those sound the same, so I'm wondering if the same motor was used in all of them. Aerus did recently change their motor though, the current classic model has moved to a one stage motor, very powerful but does not sound as pleasant in my opinion.
Mike
 

Latest posts

Back
Top