Hi Rob,
I really appreciate your comments and your enthusiasm of Electrolux. I also accept your disagreements over my opinions and experiences. Despite your testimonies, I think we can both agree to disagree. Another thing we can both agree on is that an Electrolux is better than alot of newer modern vacuums on the market today and it's also certainly better to own an Electrolux than nothing pretty much. I'll admit, I was really excited when I picked up the Diplomat as my first ever Electrolux and I actually did had some first impressions of it. I had fun using it for a bit until I later realize that Electrolux couldn't become my new favorite. I mean I like it but I just don't love using it which was a shame cause I wanted to love using it.
For motors, I know one thing for sure is that bigger is not always better. I have no problem with SEBO or any high end company using a smaller motor that's designed to last just as long if not longer than older bigger motors. In fact the Windsor Versamatics in the states have changed from using a bigger double fan Domel motor to a smaller single fan Ametek motor, I think it was an upgrade for them but feel free to disagree. Aerus did a similar thing when they switched from a double fan motor to a single fan motor on their canisters, I wasn't a fan of that.
For circuit boards, I honestly wouldn't mind them as long as there isn't so much circuitry inside. I loved the Miele C1 Classic Homecare Powerline when I worked at a Miele dealer, there were ZERO problems during my time there even before I was recruited. If I were to recommend or own a Miele, that'd be the one I'd buy. No need to look into their higher end models. I like that those circuit boards help not overload the motor when you start it up especially if you were to plug it in with the switch still on. And by lowering the speed, you're also reducing energy unlike lowering the suction valve. So I'd definitely take the risk of owning a machine with a circuit board like that. Not to mention Miele hadn't always used circuit boards and Electrolux hadn't always kept it simple. I still remember my first day working at my first vacuum store years ago when my friend aka my boss was working on the Renaissance circuit board, he tried to bypass it but couldn't. Of course those boards have since been discontinued. But even if my Miele lasted 20 years like it's designed to and can't get parts for anymore, chances are that by then Miele would come out with something even better for me to upgrade. I know I would've rather upgraded from a Renaissance to a Guardian Platinum but trading in a Miele for another Miele is a far cheaper option. Overall, the C1 Powerline is the best Miele I've used by far even better than my Red Star and not related to the topic but also my Dynamic U1 Salsa upright.
For hoses, for storing away Electrolux may be better but I don't like how heavy the wire reinforced hoses are and how restrictive they are to airflow especially for their central vacs. I've seen the difference in a comparison video a long time ago between an Electrolux with a wire reinforced hose and a IEC Tristar with a crushproof hose. Not to mention if someone steps on the hose, chances are it would get crushed and I'm basically screwed to where I'd have to order a new hose. I wish Electrolux had the option just like Hayden where you can order a crush proof hose for your canister or any of their vacuums. I never had a problem with my crush proof low voltage central vac hoses that are the same thing as my Miele Red Star.
For maneuverability, reread my other post. The Diplomat I have was really annoying to pull around on my thicker carpets even on my thinner ones as well. The tank was not only heavy but long where it was hard to pull from the hallway into a bedroom door corner without scratching off any paint or cause a mark on the door molding. The older metal tanks ones may have been better but I'd rather not have a taller canister like my Rainbow E2, that one was annoying to use as well.
For price, I don't think I'd save more with an Electrolux. A brand new Lux Classic the last time I recalled was like almost $2,000 if not more (I don't know their MSRP). Definitely can get a Miele or a SEBO for way less than that even a Lindhaus if they were still importing those over here. For parts, I believe it's very unlikely for me to see anything ever fail on a vacuum long term since I take the best care of my stuff usually. Lindhaus I'll admit did had technical issues but they've later fixed them from my understanding. I'm sure they exited the canister market cause they weren't selling well here. My Miele Red Star when I picked it up used, there's absolutely no problems to it. Even the hose and cord rewinder still work. Yes prices are not cheap to replace although the cost of replacing parts on a Miele would probably still be cheaper for me in the long haul than owning a Lux Classic. Yes bags and filters aren't cheap either to maintain but so is Electrolux, at least by looking at the Aerus store. Thank goodness for generics but not for Miele. Luckily my Red Star can get away with using generic bags and filters because it doesn't use a Vortex motor but I'm a type of person that'd prefer using genuine stuff. We both can also agree that putting a bag in a Electrolux is so easy that there's no way a consumer can get it in wrong. However I will say though that I don't like how small the Electrolux bags are. Miele bags are getting smaller like Electrolux but I can stuff them like a pillow easily before replacing another bag on a Lux.
For filtration, an Electrolux may filter well but there is a flaw I've noticed. Air blows out of the cord rewinder. Never happened before on a Miele, SEBO, or Lindhaus that I've used. So I'd say no that's not a win for Electrolux in my books.
And finally, I've seen that comparison video before and I don't believe it was an accurate test. Notice that particle counter is made by non other than IQAir. An air purifier company and it's specifically designed to test out air purifiers, not vacuums from my understanding. In addition, I've seen different videos of the same particle counter used both by Alex and other vacuum stores testing the same vacuums. Opposite results. So that video got me to question if Alex's scanner at the time was malfunctioning which I remember him mentioning before he had to get his serviced or it's just not the correct scanner to test on vacuums.
Anyways, thanks for the conversation Rob and hope you're doing well overall! I believe it's great that you prefer Electrolux over the modern machines, I'd say just keep using what you like and I'll use what I like. At least you'll be happy to hear that I'll continue to find more Electrolux vacuums for my collection
