I think
Miele's are great.......I think Kirby's are fine machines. I think Rainbow's are great. Also Sebo's, Riccar, Simplicity, etc.
but..about the water being a poor filtration medium......It's not just the water, but a combination of water/separator. If the water/separator isn't doing crap, you would need to change HEPA filters every week.
I've honestly never used my Rainbow in a very dirty environment. Since living in this house brand new I've always been a clean freak so my rainbow hasn't really had to pass too many tough challenges, not to mention the fact that I clean the separator after every single use with a toothbrush and dish soap... I mean, don't get me wrong, I've vacuumed up some nasty stuff with my rainbow - mainly other bagless vacuum bin's....but the majority of dirt it has seen is just common house dirt you would expect......nothing super filthy. But with all that, the HEPA lasted me 5 years. I can clean my entire house on one filling usually but sometimes change it once just to be safe.
Think about it. If someone isn't in a very clean home, they get their rainbow, fill it with water, start vacuuming, and I suspect 90% will keep vacuuming until the basin is getting way too thick...My Grandma bought a rainbow in the 1980s and when we would use that thing, we totally let the water get WAY too dirty. I remember dumping it outside and it was thick with dirt. Way too thick. But we didn't know. We filled it with water once, and that was it, to clean the entire house. I seriously don't remember EVER changing the water multiple times to clean the house. But we should have. She had a wood burning stove and LOTS of traffic in her house. She had her rainbow from 1984 I think until the late 90s when a Kirby guy talked her into trading. I even remember running out of scents that came with it and we put a couple of drops of pine sol....the dirt killed the foam almost immediately.
I think that was my reason for wanting a Rainbow when I moved into this new house. I remembered how awesome it smelled when we were cleaning when I was younger. I vowed to take care of mine and I have.....even though once I fell off a ladder holding it trying to clean a high place - before I bought the 14-foot hose...
but sometimes just getting it out to start cleaning is a pain. It's heavy and getting down to set it up and put it away is annoying......but your house is so fresh when you're done sometimes it's worth it. I mostly use my upright HEPA bagged vacuum now. I will still use my Rainbow sometimes.