Is a manual carpet sweeper worth it?

niclonnic

Well-known member
Premium Member
Joined
May 19, 2014
Messages
564
Location
Bonney Lake, WA
Along with vacuum cleaners, I've also had a childhood interest in carpet sweepers. I'm referring to the type that is manually operated (pushing and pulling it rotates the brushes, which in turn sweeps dirt into pans). I first used one back in elementary school, during 5th grade (20 years ago, the height of my vacuum obsession). It was a (somewhat) vintage sweeper called a "Clean Sweep by Bissell," colored in white.

Since then, I've always had a fascination with them, because for one, I've always had pretty bad sensory issues thanks to my autism. Since I couldn't use a very loud vacuum as a kid, using a simple carpet sweeper that makes a very minimal amount of noise was a huge boon for me.

When I was in high school, my main, "high needs" classroom had a Bissell Perfect Sweep, colored in mint green. Naturally, I enjoyed using that whenever I had the opportunity. But my carpet sweeper experience has been limited to school use.

Anyway, although I have been able to tolerate vacuums since I was a teen, I never really put much thought into getting a carpet sweeper for home use. But a few weeks ago, a thought occurred to me, largely brought on by a female autistic social media star. Although my Dyson DC17 Animal still works great for vacuuming the stairs and upstairs, the noise level is a bit too high, thanks to the beefy, separate-motor-driven brushroll. Since my dad and stepmom both work from home, it prevents me from using the Dyson most of the time, unless they've gone out to run errands or something. I also own an Electrolux Ergorapido stick/hand vac, but the nozzle is rather narrow and difficult to push on medium-pile carpet.

So, I've casually thought about buying a manual carpet sweeper to clean up surface dirt upstairs in between vacuumings. There are quite a lot of options on Amazon, including Bissell (the OG carpet sweeper company) and some other, smaller brands such as Yocada. Those are around the $20-30 range. Fuller Brush also exists, but their sweepers are on the expensive side, at around $80.

I'm curious to know what you all think about manual carpet sweepers. Are they worth it as a good, "in-between" cleaning tool? If so, will one be feasible for medium-pile carpets?

niclonnic-2025031716193209166_1.jpg
 
I love them!

I absolutely love those little sweepers! I have 2 of them. As for cleaning power they’re not that great, they do pick up surface debris, and some deeper down dirt and pet hair. But don’t expect a ton. We have the bisslle ones at my church. I think that would be your best option. If you want you could get the bisslle perfect sweep. It’ll clean better than a traditional non electric sweeper, they’re also extremely quiet.
-Jack

kirbyman65-2025031719022403356_1.jpg

kirbyman65-2025031719022403356_2.jpg
 
I did it

Yesterday, I ended up buying a Bissell Perfect Sweep Turbo from Amazon for just under $40; it arrived earlier this afternoon. I opened up the box and assembled the sweeper, which was a pretty straightforward process. Simply screw the handle sections together and snap the full piece into place on the lower handle.

However, there is a catch: the sweeper has to be charged for at least 16 hours prior to the first use, preventing me from using it right away. I did briefly turn on the sweeper, and the noise level is nice and quiet. Bissell claims up to 60 minutes (1 hour) of run time.

On the bright side, this sweeper has a NiMH battery, which thankfully doesn't have memory issues unlike the old NiCad ones.

Once the sweeper is fully charged, I'll give it a good test run. There are bits of dirt and dry leaves scattered around my bedroom carpet, which will make it a perfect testing ground.

niclonnic-2025032300292000944_1.jpg

niclonnic-2025032300292000944_2.jpg

niclonnic-2025032300292000944_3.jpg
 
Wow! I guess I really am getting old. I had no idea carpet sweepers were motorized now!
The two that I have, the brush is just "powered" by the wheels rolling.
I hope you really like it!
 
niclonic

Thanks for taking my advice! I really appreciate it! I'm sure you'll enjoy you sweeper! By the way I just remembered my golf course has one at the clubhouse!
Thanks again
-Jack
 
First impressions

I used the Perfect Sweep Turbo for the first time today, and so far, I am really impressed with it!


Pros:

1. Very effective at picking up most surface debris, including dust and hair. Just about everything is captured in the dirt cup.

2. QUIET operation! I feel pretty confident using this for quick cleanups upstairs without disturbing anyone else nearby.

3. Super lightweight, and therefore very easy to maneuver across my carpet.

4. Low profile easily gets under furniture.

5. I mentioned that Bissell claims up to 60 minutes of run time. I have only used the sweeper for several minutes, and so far, I haven't seen a drop in performance.

6. Dirt cup is easy to lift out and empty.

7. Handle detaches, converting the sweeper into a handheld one. I could see this feature being useful for cleaning a car.


Cons:

1. The dirt cup is TINY! I didn't expect it to be this small on a sweeper like this. Because of that, it fills up very quickly, due in large part to a dog and a cat who roam around upstairs daily. So the dirt cup will need to be emptied frequently if I were to use the sweeper to do the whole upstairs.

2. Dust builds up on the exterior of the sweeper, particularly in front of the brushroll.

3. Strands of hair tend to accumulate on the brushroll.

4. Power switch is somewhat difficult to press, especially without my shoes on.

5. Charging times are LONG, due to the use of a NiMH battery (not lithium-ion). The first charge took about 8-9 hours to complete.


A major reason for buying this sweeper was to clean kitty litter off the laundry room floor. My Bengal cat, LucyFurr, kicks out quite a bit of litter after doing her business, so I'm sure this machine will do its part in maintaining a litter-free floor.

JustJunque, here's a bit of a history lesson from what I have gathered: Motorized floor sweepers have actually been around since the early 2000s. Around 2002, Euro-Pro introduced the "Shark Cordless Sweeper," designed for quick and easy cleanups of everyday messes, without the need for a big, heavy vacuum. This product achieved major success through an infomercial. I'll include a link to it on YouTube.



niclonnic-2025032318102305419_1.jpg

niclonnic-2025032318102305419_2.jpg
 
I had a Shark cordless sweeper before, it was nice while it lasted. I also had a Bissell GoVac which I didn't liked as much. I was nearly close to getting a Dirt Devil cordless sweeper back in like 2004 I believe but went with something else instead. I don't think I'll ever get another cordless sweeper again but if I did, I'd get a Bissell BG9100NM. I like that you can get replacement batteries and other parts for it. They've also sold that in other brands including Oreck and my personal favorite brand Panasonic.



As for push sweepers, I had a really old Bissell that belonged to my great grandparents. Wish I kept it still. Now I have one of those old Dirt Devils from like the 90's. Not a huge fan of them really. But if I had to have one, I'd get a Bissell BG25 which is the same type that my great grandparents had. I thought it was decent for what it was.
 
Pizza Sweeper...

I remember using one of those when I worked for Pizza Hut back in the early '80s. Of course, it was a manual model back then. We used it for quick cleanups when there were customers in the dining room (yeah, this was back when Pizza Hut was primarily a sit-down chain before Domino's upended the paradigm). I don't recall that it worked all that well, but I'm sure it was well past its peak with all the wear and tear it received. Our other vacuum was a Craftsman wet/dry shop vac that we were only allowed to use after we were closed because of the noise it made.
 
If you have short pile or have an area that gets lots of food crumbs you can get a motorized one. I'd never use one as my sole vacuum myself. I have a more advanced one for outdoors to do my driveway.

i have tons of antique ones I pick up if I can find them cheap.

I've only ever seen them used in diners where you don't need to stir up dust and make noise while people eat.
 
One Week Update

First off, huskyvacs, I already bought a motorized sweeper last week, the Bissell Perfect Sweep Turbo. So here are my further thoughts on it.

I've been using the sweeper upstairs to keep the medium-pile carpet clean. It has been doing great at picking up pet hair and other surface dirt, along with some dust. Not to mention, the cat litter is swept right off the laundry room floor. The brushroll does leave some nice lines on the carpet, almost as if it were vacuumed with a full-sized machine.

The other day, I detached the handle to convert the sweeper into a handheld one, so I could use it on stairs. My cat treats the carpeted steps as a scratchpost, so she naturally leaves a lot of loose fibers all over the place. The Perfect Sweep Turbo did very well on the stairs, although the fibers spun around in the brushroll for a bit before making their way into the dirt cup.

So far, battery life has been impressive. Since I fully charged the sweeper last week, I have not seen a drop in power, even with moderately heavy usage.

The one thing to keep in mind is that the Perfect Sweep Turbo is NOT a vacuum; therefore it does not use suction. Instead, the brushroll spins and propels dirt into a removable cup. This makes the sweeper VERY quiet during operation. Because of this simple principle, the sweeper will not replace a full-sized vacuum. Rather, I use the sweeper for casual cleaning in between regular vacuumings, without disturbing anyone else nearby. I keep it upstairs, in the laundry room, so I can easily grab the sweeper and clean whenever I see a dirty room.

Overall, I'm very happy with this purchase. For just under $40, the Bissell Perfect Sweep Turbo is a great way to keep hard floors clean, along with getting surface dirt off the carpets in a more discreet manner.

niclonnic-2025033018491207401_1.jpg

niclonnic-2025033018491207401_2.jpg
 
Electric Straight Suction Sweepers

The good ol'-fashioned manual sweepers are a thing at family restaurants, because during peak times electric vacuums aren't used because their noise drowns out other sounds.

That said, how many of you have thought of going back to using straight-suction electric upright cleaners? Among them were Royal's 311 for heavy-duty commercial use, and the Electro-Hygiene 80, 94 and (2)-230.

~Ben
 
Ben

I have been looking for a strait suction royal, but I can’t seem to find them anywhere in my area! If I find one cheap I’ll probably buy it.
-Jack
 

Latest posts

Back
Top